 |
|
Title: The Song of the Dodo: Island Biogeography in an Age of Extinction
ISBN: 0684827123
Author:
David Quammen
Publicate Date: 1997-04-14
Publish: 1997-04-14
List Price: $22.00
Average Customer Rating: 4.5
Format: Paperback
 |
|
|
|
|
Amazon Lowest New Price: $9.99
Amazon Lowest Used Price: $4.89
Amazon Merchant Price: $14.96
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Customer Review: |
|
1: Substantial and informative
At 625 text pages, this is a substantial book and well worth the time devoted to reading it. It does not assume a lot of background in biology or ecology in the reader but, interestingly enough, instructs the reader along the way. If you were unversed in the species-area concept, you will learn. If the distance effect, genetic drift, and allopatric speciation were not your strong points, you will learn. In fact this book seems to have quite good potential as a teaching text. It is not only instructive, but entertaining. The author has done quite a job to put together a large volume such as this, one that does such a good job of teaching and of making the learning pleasant. You will learn something and you will enjoy the learning. Along the way, you will learn the sad stories of the species lost by the dozens, hundreds, thousands, because of one. Us. The tragic tale is told in 171 short pieces, each a sort of small essay on some particular animal or island or person. The author, we learn, did not merely sit down at his desk and punch out this text at his typewriter. Rather, he actually travelled to many of the places he described. He visited some of the researchers in their offices or in the field. This author was at many of the places he describes. The result is a book that is one of a few that I would recommend to someone asking for a short list of introductory books on the subject of evolution and ecology.
|
2: Hard science in a readable text
Quammen does an exceptional job of explaining why biogeography should be important to you. He offers a scientific, historical, and personal narrative. As a professional biologist, I like the accuracy in bringing theory to a general audience. For students of biology, if reading MacArthur and Wilson's paper left you a little perplexed, this is the book that will smooth out those rough edges and assure that you "get it". The book probably holds little interest for people who aren't serious science buffs, but even for interested laypersons, there is enough of a narrative running through the text to make it an easy, sensible read. Suffers from flaws of historical perspective, but none so blatant as to make this text unworthy. Highly recommended.
|
3: Science Journalism? Yeh, it rules!
This is the first book I've read by Quammen, an imminently talented journalist who perfectly balances the information and writing style of the book. He follows a chronological progression of island biogeography from Darwin through Jared Diamond (who became hugely famous shortly after the release of this book). Quammen's travelogues are excellent, combining a sympathetic, open perspective that is adventurous and engaged. Late in the book, Quammen describes a climb to the nest of a Mauritius kestrel: "When I'm thirty feet up, a tree branch flicks off my glasses, which drop to the ground. I could go down and retrieve them, sure, that would be sensible, but I'd fall too far behind the cheerful maniacs...
'Do you trust this vine?' I call up to Jones. Gangly but tall, he must weigh two hundred pounds, and from this angle I can appreciate the size of his feet.
'Not greatly.'
We ratchet our way upward, slowly, on the cliff face. It isn't Half Dome but it's more perilous than the average birdwatching stroll. We rise out above the valley. As we move beyond the treetops, I give myself an explicit mental reminder: Fall from here and you don't go home. Finally, Jones and I catch up with Lewis on a narrow rock shelf, like a window ledge ten stories above Lexington Avenue...
I gaze out at the panorama--the forested canyon below us, the deer ranch beyond, and the cane plantation beyond that, all spreading westward for five miles to the crescent of beach and then the great turquoise plane of the Indian Ocean." (562-3)
It's Quammen's excitement and sensitivty that inspire the reader to continue and to care, to take notice of humanity's influence: carving nature into islands, resulting in astonishing rates of extinction and ecosystem decay. But Quammen urges us to cling to hope, not despair, because "besides being fruitless it's far less exciting than hope, however slim." (636)
|
4: Desultory fluff
This is by far the most desultory, fluff-filled history of biological evolution that I've ever read. Generally, I am not a skimmer of Quammen's work, and in fact often enjoy his wit and lithesome prose, but after only a dozen pages or so into Dodo I found myself flipping page after page looking for something substantive, looking for meat. In one word, the pace is SLOW. Over and over again in the margins I found myself scribbling "Go! Go! We'd advanced this far thirty pages ago!" But on the plus side I suppose if you are looking for a book to practice your speed reading, Dodo may be it: you can flip ten pages at a throw and hardly miss a thing.
|
5: Fabulous
Quammen's book is a rare bird--a clearly written science book that doesn't condescend to readers. It's long enough to go fairly deep, and deep enough to be interesting: it's on my short list of favorites.
As other reviewers point out, the history of squabbles wears a little thin, but neither Darwin nor anyone else sticks in my memory as having been unfairly kneecapped. In fact, the only faintly negative impression I had was of the excessive care Quammen takes in presenting some fairly basic math. Highly recommended.
|
|
|
|
|
