 |
|
Title: 100 Love Sonnets: Cien sonetos de amor (Texas Pan American Series) (Spanish Edition)
ISBN: 0292760280
Author:
Pablo Neruda
Publicate Date: 1986
Publish: 1986
List Price: $16.95
Average Customer Rating: 4.5
Format: Paperback
 |
|
|
|
|
Amazon Lowest New Price: $6.85
Amazon Lowest Used Price: $3.91
Amazon Merchant Price: $11.53
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Customer Review: |
|
1: Can i just say..
that this book ranks #4 on my top10 favorite books list. And yes, i have a favorite book list.
Guess what my number one is.... =]
|
2: Pablo Neruda's 100 Love Sonnets
This is a beautifully crafted book. If you want to impress your wife, leave one of these love poems on her pillow. A Sure Hit!
|
3: Tapscott's liberties
Am reading through Pablo Neruda's 100 Love Sonnets for a second time. A lot of the Amazon customer reviews for this book mentioned that the translator, Stephen Tapscott, produced English versions laden with inaccuracies and liberties and errors. I must admit: I haven't studied Spanish since elementary school, but I think I can glean enough from the en face Spanish of Neruda's original language that I can safely agree with this assessment.
Tapscott routinely renders singulars as plurals, and plurals as singulars. The same Spanish word, "roc??o," is rendered "dew" in one place and "soft rain" in another. In sonnet IX alone, we have "restless" for "ind??cil" (are restlessness and indocility the same thing?), and "dazzling lurch of the sea" for "deslumbrante movimiento marino."
Allowing for the fact that a translator must occasionally use synonyms and avoid cognates, is "lurch of the sea" really the best choice? The alliteration is lost, and the meaning is changed to something that, perhaps, Neruda would not want. "Marine movement" would be equally unacceptable; it is flat, and "movement" sounds a little odd. "Motion," perhaps? "Maritime motion." I'm not equipped to translate Spanish into an English that can be called poetry, but I'm fairly certain that "lurch" is a mistake, as it gives us more Tapscott than Neruda.
Having said all this, Tapscott is brave enough to give us Neruda's original sonnets, so we can compare Tapscott's English to the Nobel laureate's Spanish. It is perhaps inevitable that Tapscott would suffer in the comparison. And these translations, however flawed, do open up the Sonnets to those of us who are Spanish-impaired.
Some memorable lines:
sonnet 78, "Yo pagu?? la vileza con palomas" ("I repaid vileness with doves");
sonnet 81, "tus ojos se cerraron como dos alas grises" ("your eyes closed like two gray wings");
sonnet 84,
"una copa en que cae la ceniza celeste,
una gota en el pulso de un lento y largo r??o"
("a chalice filling with celestial ashes,
a drop in the pulse of a long slow river");
sonnet 100,
"Ya no habr?? sino todo el aire libre,
las manzanas llevadas por el viento,
el suculento libro en la enramada,
"y all?? donde respiran los claveles
fundaremos un traje que resista
la eternidad de un beso victorioso"
("There won't be anything but all the fresh air,
apples carried on the wind,
the succulent book in the woods:
"and there where the carnations breathe, we will begin
to make ourselves a clothing, something to last
through the eternity of a victorious kiss").
Five stars out of five for Neruda's sonnets, three stars for Tapscott's translations.
|
4: Awesome!
It is a masterpiece of latin-american literature. It is a new experience into the depths of the human heart. It has unique metaphors and similies that picture the most passionate and simple type of love!
|
5: When you cannot find the words to express how you are feel!
Without a doubt, truly one of the best love sonnets. Huge fan of Pablo Neruda and thrilled to have a copy of this book.
|
|
|
|
|
