 |
|
Title: The Penguin Companion to Classical Music
ISBN: 0140515593
Author:
Paul Griffiths
Publicate Date: 2005-08-30
Publish: 2005-08-30
List Price: $25.00
Average Customer Rating: 4.5
Format: Paperback
 |
|
|
|
|
Amazon Lowest New Price: $2.99
Amazon Lowest Used Price: $2.69
Amazon Merchant Price: $16.50
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Customer Review: |
|
1: Idiosyncracy not defined
I happily side with most of what reviewer Morrison has said. A very engaging work, fun to dip into and the ideal bedside reading. As a work of reference,however, it violates a tenet, namely that scope,intent and any idiosyncracies be clearly set forth for the prospective buyer/user. Instead, the author indulges in all sorts of caprice, with the end result that you never know when to grab this book, rather than another, to look something up in. Here's a list of missing names which every music lover will recognize: Kipnis (both father/singer and son/harpsichordist & scholar), Abendroth, Schuricht, Scherchen (Conductors; in the latter's case all the more absurd since his daughter, Scherchen-Hsiao gets an entry); Quasthoff, Rethberg, Hanson, Netrebko, Pape, Schlusnus, Rosvaenge, Schorr, Battle, Cebotari, Battistini, Gobbi, Ivogun, Erb, Kirkby, Schipa, Muzio, Vinay, Varnay, Thorborg, Simionato (Singers - and all of them first rank. Conversely, Lily Pons and Maria Jeritza who were better known for their looks than their vocal art, are included); Moravec, Solomon, Wild, Kapell, Katchen, Larrocha, Gulda, Anda, Watts, Cziffra, Kempff, Friedman (pianists). The Juilliard and Budapest Quartets are in, the Emerson and Hollywood String Quartets are out. We have frivolous/superfluous entries for Francoise Sagan's novel 'Aimez-vous Brahms', and for Chester Kallman. And for Richard Wagner, the author is warming up the hoary story once again about his paternity having "never been resolved". The subject became a matter of interest in certain quarters when Geyer, who became Wagner's stepfather after the father's death, was thought to have been Jewish (this started with Nietzsche). Since it has been established to be utterly without substance, it has made the paternity issue irrelevant. Wagner himself never thought that Geyer was his father.
A last word about his choice of singers: He didn't miss a single prominent Richard Strauss interpreter!
|
2: A Book for Dipping Into or For Reading Cover-to-Cover
I'm more than a little surprised that this book, published in August 2005, hadn't already received a review by the time of my own review here in mid-February 2006. There has been a lot of buzz about the book, not least because it is the work of one man: Paul Griffiths, former music critic of The New Yorker and the New York Times. The book goes toe to toe with other similar books like the Oxford Dictionary of Music or the Harvard Dictionary of Music, and others of that ilk. It appears to me to be the equal of those which were written by committees of musicologists. And it has the advantage of putting forth the viewpoints of a single author. I found myself browsing with utter delight. My problem with browsing was that when I was referred from an article on, say, Beethoven to one on Handel, I would get side-tracked when, as I turned pages, I came across an article on Frau ohne Schatten, Mirella Freni, or the French sixth. But then that's part of the pleasure of a book of this sort. I took to writing down where I wanted to eventually get to in the book because most times I would get so caught up in the intervening reading that I'd forgotten where I had intended to go.
The book contains short articles (and some not so short -- the one on Beethoven, for instance, takes six pages) on innumerable topics, covered in nearly 900 pages. It covers composers well-known (Beethoven, Bach, Brahms) and those barely heard of (Franchetti, Nanino, Gruenberg), as well as instrumentalists, music publishers, conductors, singers and the like. Basic (and some not-so-basic) musical terms are defined and sometimes examples given. There are articles on the various musical instruments and their histories, as well as disquisitions on various musical forms, techniques, styles, artistic movements et al. There are brief articles on important musical works (e.g. Goldberg Variations) and he provides brief synopses of operas.
Griffiths writes in a smooth modern authoritative-yet-casual style that is extremely easy to read; this is no surprise as he is also a published poet and novelist. He includes enough oddities and rare facts to make a grizzled veteran like myself want to keep reading. Yet he covers the basics without becoming pedantic or pompous. When in an article he uses an abbreviation or set of initials (e.g. LSO: London Symphony Orchestra) one can find the definition under the alphabetical listing for that term. One small deficiency is that he makes no effort to provide pronunciations of non-English terms. As in any work of this scope, he has had to make decisions about what to include and what to leave out. Thus, pianist Marc-Andr?? Hamelin rates an article, but his pianistic colleague Stephen Hough does not. One is amazed, though, at how much he manages to include without the work assuming truly gargantuan proportions; in its paperback format the book is easy to handle and will not break your toe if you drop it. It has an attractive format, the paper is sturdy and the print easy to read.
This book would be a valuable addition to any musiclover's library. Strongly recommended.
Scott Morrison
|
|
|
|
|
